Echos

Image representing Last.fm as depicted in Crun...

Image via CrunchBase

It started off as a reply to the usual Spotify vs Last.fm debate on teh social networks recently. When my reply was getting longer than the rest of the thread, I decided that it should probably belong here.

In context, Spotify is doing the rounds in the media and social networks for reducing their ad-free listening time[1]. In short, for services that one would use… they’re asking for £5 a month.

Personally, I’m in the Last.fm camp.

It’s £3 for unrestricted listening. Free accounts let you do (almost) everything, access to some free songs provided by kind artists, full streams using the desktop app (which actually just downloads a normal MP3) and a full api to complement other on-demand services such as grooveshark, amazonMP3 and for local/network files, Media Player/VLC support. I also supports scrobbling from Spotify too, jus’ sayin’. It won’t cut you off from music after 600 minutes in a month.

On Friday, free accounts will notice a few ads, but no requirement to commit in the UK. There’s a list of alternatives at [2]. I might have a look at hypemachine, not sure what their model is, but there’s a large full width banner saying that it makes last.fm awesome. Their adjective, not mine.

For free, (in the UK) you can stream directly from the last.fm radio service. Pick by artist, tag or user and you are brought into an auto-generated playlist. Once there, your options are to listen, enjoy (and love) the tune, skip to another track of similar audio properties (maybe you’ve just heard that song too much today), ban the track from ever descending your ears again (this has consequences). As of [3], you can even pause tracks too, yes an announcement was necessary[4].

There’s even an open source[5] desktop client (written in Qt. Yay!), and corresponding ebuild[6].

The last.fm API is extensive[7]. It’s well documented, the desktop scrobbler serves as a very good example/reference implementation for the API. There are many creative ideas that can be spawned from the API[8], some are quite exciting. You are even protected from vendor lock-in[9] and are free to do what you want with your data.

The people behind last.fm aren’t that evil. They know that people don’t like to pay for something that they previously got for free, but they need money too. If you want some of it, they are hiring[10].

10 hours in a month is a lot for a mobile contract. Not that good for music browsing.
in a 30 day month, that is 1 hour for 3 days, or 20 mins per day. That’s enough to get me into work, but leaves me deaf for the road back.

I’ve been with last.fm since the beta, they gave me a few months free subscription. If I’m being honest, it’s been really useful having unrestricted access. With a subscription, you can stream to mobile and dedicated hardware[11].

For £3 a month, unrestricted listening on any device, serendipity in the form of artist profiles and social networks and integration across the board, it’s a good deal.

[1] http://www.spotify.com/se/blog/archives/2011/04/14/upcoming-changes-to-spotify-free-open/
[2] http://www.last.fm/help/faq?category=98#220
[3] http://www.last.fm/help/faq?category=98#287
[4] http://blog.last.fm/2011/04/13/lastfm-now-supporting-tea-breaks
[5] svn://svn.audioscrobbler.net/clientside/Last.fm
[6] http://gentoo-portage.com/media-sound/lastfmplayer
[7] http://www.last.fm/api
[8] http://build.last.fm/
[9] http://foocorp.org/projects/fm/faq/ [10] http://www.last.fm/about/jobs
[11] http://www.robertsradio.co.uk/Products/Internet_radios/STREAM83i/index.htm It even has dedicated love/ban buttons.

Advertisements

4 comments

    • bencord0

      I didn’t mention Grooveshark, but I am a fan. Grooveshark is a good middle ground with on demand music, and last.fm scrobbling. At the moment, I can’t justify to myself having both a GS and last.fm subscription. Grooveshark does have a radio mode, but I find it limited and serendipity experiences are far less common.

      On that note, I can’t overlook the effect that the Pandora project has. I was also an early adopter of the music genome project before it got locked down to the US only. It’s a simple model, a machine learning algorithm tracks what you (and others similar to you) like and generates the next track based on heuristics and maths. Love/Hate buttons ftw.

      If I could get the ♥ and ⃠ (unicode 20E0 if you have a bad renderer) buttons for my car radio. I really like [11].

  1. Mark

    Yeah, I have to agree that Grooveshark’s radio mode isn’t much good. I typically randomly remember music that it would be nice to listen to and favourite it: I then play all of my favourites. It’s annoying when some of those randomly disappear for copyright reasons though. The US seems to do much better for similar services, which is a great shame.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s